Peanut Butter Lover's 4" 4-Pack

$38.00
$44.00 $38.00
Save 13%

Rich peanut butter meets melt-in-your-mouth toffee in this nutty dream team. With two peanut butter cup skillet cookies and two toffee cookies, this pack brings salty-sweet perfection in every bite.

Inside the Batch

Original 4" Skillet
Original 4" Skillet
Contains Nuts

2x Peanut Butter Cup Cookie

Original 4" Skillet
Original 4" Skillet

2x Toffee Cookie

Contains Nuts A flavor in this pack includes nuts. Please skip if you have a nut allergy.

4" Original Skillet (Serves 2–4) The perfect shareable size for movie nights, study breaks, or when you pretend you’ll save half for later.

>

Next Bake Day is Monday All orders placed today will be baked Monday and shipped Tuesday. All orders are baked in bulk on Mondays and shipped Tuesdays & Wednesdays!

Fresh batches baked every Monday Shipped out every Tuesday & Wednesday!

Skillet Cookies in the mail?

Yes, this is real life.

Where the Magic Begins
Our bakers fire up the ovens bright and early every Monday morning
Cookie Delivery Day
Once cooled and sealed, your cookies hit the road Tuesday or Wednesday (if we are backed up)
Fridge ’Em or Feast ’Em
Enjoy within 1 week at room temp or pop ’em in the fridge for up to two weeks
Fresh in Seconds
Toss in the microwave for 15-30 seconds to enjoy warm
Shop Now

Size Is Everything

Not sure which skillet size is right for you? Slide to see how big your sweeth tooth is!

Fresh cookie skillet – Original
Shop Skillets

Customer Reviews